Skip to main content
Home
Solidarity Federation
Section of the International Workers Association
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
User account menu
  • Contact
  • Log in
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
  • Home
    • About SolFed
    • Workplace organiser training
    • Industrial strategy
    • Community strategy
    • Constitution
  • SolFed
    • Brighton
    • Bristol
    • Edinburgh
    • Liverpool
    • Manchester
    • North London
    • Wales
    • Yorkshire
  • Industries and sectors
    • Claimants and unpaid
    • Education
    • Health and social care
    • Hospitality
  • Events & reports
  • Publications
    • Guides
      • Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)
      • Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)
      • Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)
      • Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016) [en es]
      • A migrant's guide to London (2014) [en es pl]
      • Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)
    • Pamphlets and books
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)
      • Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)
      • Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)
      • The Economics of freedom (2003)
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism (2001)
      • Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)
      • Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)
    • Leaflets and flyers
      • Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU)
      • Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)
      • What is wage theft?
      • Why do we organise?
      • This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for
      • What is anarcho-syndicalism anyway?
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism (short version)
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism
      • Towards a better union
      • Protest is not enough
      • Building beyond elections
      • We should run our workplaces
      • We should run our communities
      • We should run our movements
    • Posters and stickers
    • Newsletters
      • Brighton Solidarity
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #2 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #4 (Winter 2014)
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (Summer 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #2 (Spring 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #1 (Jan 2012)
        • Brighton Solidarity - spending review special (Oct 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity - emergency budget special (Jun 2010)
        • Brighton Agitator #1 (Mar 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity (Winter 2007)
      • Communication Worker
        • Communication Worker #8 (Jul 2001)
        • Communication Worker #7 (Jan 2001)
        • Communication Worker #6
        • Communication Worker #5
        • Communication Worker bulletin
      • Education Worker
        • Education Worker #10 (Apr 2013)
        • Education Worker #9 (Oct 2012)
        • Education Worker #8 (Mar 2012)
        • Education Worker #7 (Mar 2011)
        • Education Worker #6 (Jan 2011)
        • Education Worker #5 (Oct 2009)
        • Education Worker #4 (May 2009)
        • Education Worker #3 (Sep 2008)
        • Education Worker #2 (Jan 2008)
        • Education Worker #1 (2007)
        • Education Worker #9 (Summer 2002)
        • Education Worker #8 - special higher education issue (2002)
      • The Leveller
        • The Leveller #19 (May-Jul 2017)
        • The Leveller #18 (Aug 2016)
        • The Leveller #17 (Mar 2015)
        • The Leveller #17 (Dec 2014)
        • The Leveller #16 (Nov 2014)
        • The Leveller #15 (May 2014)
        • The Leveller #14 (Mar 2014)
        • The Leveller #13 (May 2013)
        • The Leveller #12 (Jun-Jul 2012)
        • The Leveller #11 (May 2012)
        • The Leveller #10 (Apr 2012)
        • The Leveller #9 (Mar 2012)
        • The Leveller #6 (May-Jul 2011)
      • Liverpool Anarchist
        • Liverpool Anarchist #21 (Apr 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #20 (Mar 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #19 (Feb 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #18 (Dec 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #17 (Nov 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #16 (Oct 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #15 (Sep 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #14 (Aug 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #13 (Jul 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #12 (Jun 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #11 (Apr 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #10 (Dec 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #9 (Oct 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #8 (Aug 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #7 (Jul 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #6 (Mar 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #5 (Feb 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #4 (Jan 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #3 (Dec 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #2 (Nov 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #1 (Oct 2019)
      • May Day Bulletin (Newcastle, 2014)
      • Public Service Workers Network bulletin
        • Public Service Workers Network #8 (Winter 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #6 (Spring 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #5 (Oct-Nov 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #4 (Jun-Jul 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #3 (Autumn 1993)
      • Spanner in the Works (West Yorkshire, April 2013)
      • Wildcat!
        • Wildcat! #13 (Jan 2013)
        • Wildcat! (Winter 2012)
        • Wildcat! #6 (Summer 2011)
        • Wildcat! #5 (Spring 2011)
        • Wildcat! #4 (Dec 2010)
        • Wildcat! #3 (Oct-Nov 2010)
        • Wildcat! #2 (Jul-Aug 2010)
        • Wildcat! Football for the fans NOT for fat cats! (Jul 2010)
        • Wildcat! #1 (May-June 2010)
    • Direct Action
      • Direct Action - Solidarity Federation
        • Direct Action #2
        • Direct Action #1
        • Direct Action #48 (Autumn 2009)
        • Direct Action #47 (Summer 2009)
        • Direct Action #46 (Spring 2009)
        • Direct Action #45 (Winter 2008)
        • Direct Action #44 (Autumn 2008)
        • Direct Action #43 (Summer 2008)
        • Direct Action #42 (Spring 2008)
        • Direct Action #41 (Winter 2007)
        • Direct Action #40 (Autumn 2007)
        • Direct Action #39 (Summer 2007)
        • Direct Action #38 (Spring 2007)
        • Direct Action #37 (Autumn-Winter 2006)
        • Direct Action #36 (Spring-Summer 2006)
        • Direct Action #35 (Summer 2005)
        • Direct Action #34 (Spring 2005)
        • Direct Action #33 (Winter 2004)
        • Direct Action #32 (Autumn 2004)
        • Direct Action #31 (Summer 2004)
        • Direct Action #30 (Spring 2004)
        • Direct Action #29 (Winter 2003)
        • Direct Action #28 (Autumn 2003)
        • Direct Action #27 (Summer 2003)
        • Direct Action #26 (Spring 2003)
        • Direct Action #25 (Winter 2002)
        • Direct Action #24 (Autumn 2002)
        • Direct Action #23 (Summer 2002)
        • Direct Action #22 (Spring 2002)
        • Direct Action #21 (Winter 2001)
        • Direct Action #20 (Autumn 2001)
        • Direct Action #19 (Summer 2001)
        • Direct Action #18 (Spring 2001)
        • Direct Action #17 (Winter 2000)
        • Direct Action #16 (Autumn 2000)
        • Direct Action #15 (Summer 2000)
        • Direct Action #14 (Spring 2000)
        • Direct Action #13 (Winter 1999)
        • Direct Action #12 (Autumn 1999)
        • Direct Action #11 (Summer 1999)
        • Direct Action #10 (Spring 1999)
        • Direct Action #9 (Winter 1998)
        • Direct Action #8 (Autumn 1998)
        • Direct Action #7 (Summer 1998)
        • Direct Action #6 (Spring 1998)
        • Direct Action #5 (Winter 1997)
        • Direct Action #4 (Autumn 1997)
        • Direct Action #3 (Summer 1997)
        • Direct Action #2 (Spring 1997)
        • Direct Action #1 (Autumn 1996)
        • Direct Action #2 (Winter 1994)
        • Direct Action #1 (Summer 1994)
    • Catalyst
      • Catalyst - Solidarity Federation
        • Catalyst #31 (Oct 2013)
        • Catalyst #29 (Feb 2012)
        • Catalyst #28 (Oct 2011)
        • Catalyst #27 (Jun 2011)
        • Catalyst #26 (Mar 2011)
        • Catalyst #25 (Dec 2010)
        • Catalyst #24 (Summer 2010)
        • Catalyst #23 (Spring 2010)
        • Catalyst #22 (Winter 2009)
        • Catalyst #21 (Summer 2009)
        • Catalyst #20 (Sping 2009)
        • Catalyst #19 (Nov 2008)
        • Catalyst #18 (Sep 2008)
        • Catalyst #17 (July 2008)
        • Catalyst #16 (Spring 2007)
        • Catalyst #15 (Autumn 2006)
        • Catalyst #14 (Spring 2006)
        • Catalyst #13 (Summer 2005)
        • Catalyst #12 (Apr 2005)
        • Catalyst #11 (Sep 2004)
        • Catalyst #10 (May 2004)
        • Catalyst #9 (Spring 2004)
        • Catalyst #8 (Autumn 2003)
        • Catalyst #7 (May 2003)
        • Catalyst #6 (Dec 2002)
        • Catalyst #5 (Dec 2001)
        • Catalyst #4 (May 2001)
        • Catalyst #3 (Feb 2001)
        • Catalyst #2 (Sep 2000)
        • Catalyst #1 (May 2000)
    • SelfEd
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism
    • Reference
      • Student Radicals - an incomplete history of protest at the University of Sussex 1971-1975 (Ed Goddard, 2011)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in the 20th Century (Vadim Damier, 2009)
      • Tom Brown's Syndicalism (1990)
      • Trade unionism or syndicalism? (Tom Brown, 1943)
      • The General Strike - vol 1 no 1 (Sam Mainwaring, 15 Feb 1904)
  • IWA

G4Lets: one group of tenants reclaim £1000 stolen from their deposit, whilst another receives a rent reduction for poor quality accommodation

By drumlit, 24 March, 2019

xSince September 2018, we have been organising with two different groups of tenants – one who had their deposit stolen by G4Lets, and one living in accommodation in a serious state of disrepair. We’re pleased to report that both of these situations concluded well, with the first group of tenants receiving £1000 back from their stolen deposit, and the second group receiving a rent reduction for the poor quality of their accommodation, and with the works being carried out. Below is the story of these two disputes, particularly how they relate to our previous disputes with G4Lets and the tactics we used in these two most recent disputes.

From November 2017 until March 2018, Brighton Solidarity Federation was in dispute with the student lettings agency G4Lets. We were organising with two different groups of tenants – one who’d had £2000 withheld from their deposit, and one who’d had £1000 withheld. Our four-month public campaign, which included pickets, phone pickets, stalls at university campuses, articles published on our website about the millionaire landlords they were protecting, and articles about the dispute in the local student media, placed considerable pressure on G4Lets, who responded with acts of intimidation and threats of police involvement. However, they did not pay up the £3000 stolen deposit money plus compensation that we were demanding. We analysed the likely reasons for that here Chief amongst them, we suspect, was their fear of setting a precedent. Over the course of our campaign, we heard from countless other G4Lets tenants who’d had their deposits stolen – caving to a public campaign would likely have set a precedent that G4Lets couldn’t afford.

As a result of this, we’ve had to rethink our approach to agencies such as G4Lets. They are a small agency, with one office in a residential area in Brighton with little footfall, meaning that whilst they hated the pickets, it was difficult to damage them economically in this way. Further, they advertise their properties through a website called StuRents, which means that most students – who often take places on the strength of the pictures alone, without going to a viewing, since they are arranging accommodation from a distance – don’t even realise that they are renting through G4Lets until they sign the contract. This means that damaging their reputation can be difficult because, whilst everyone knows they are scum, tenants often don’t realise they are renting through them until it’s too late.

One of the positives of our campaign was how many other G4Lets tenants approached us wanting to organise against them. In September 2018, for example, we were approached by a group of tenants who were facing deductions of just under £1900 from their deposit. The reasons for this were the classic nonsense that G4Lets come out with – that they needed to repaint the walls; that they had to clean already clean houses; that they had to replace items that it is not the tenants’ duty to maintain, and so on. Deductions like this can be really stressful – agencies lie to you about the status that you left the property in, which is an unpleasant experience, and they take money from you at a point when you need it to pay another deposit.

At the same time that this group of tenants approached us, we were also approached by a tenant and his family who had just started renting a place through G4Lets. G4Lets had rented this place out in a shocking condition: the cooker didn’t work; furniture was filthy; the room was not the size it was advertised as; sinks didn’t work; the shower was broken – the list was endless.

From our previous experience, we knew it was going to be difficult to damage G4Lets enough via direct action to make them meet any demands in these situations. With that in mind, what we did instead was organised with these tenants to go through the formal channels to address these issues. Whilst not our usual approach, it was the only one available to try and deal with the problems these tenants were having.

With the group of tenants who had £1900 taken from their deposit, we organised with them to take their dispute through the disputes procedure of the deposit protection scheme. G4Lets protect their deposits via the MyDeposits insurance scheme, which allows landlords to retain the deposit (and thus earn interest on it) over the course of the tenancy. These tenants put in a dispute with MyDeposits. We met up with them and together went through the check-in and check-out reports, highlighting all the discrepancies with the deductions G4Lets were trying to make (e.g. pointing out walls that they were claiming money to repaint that were already listed as dirty in the check-in report). We also included some legal information about the landlord’s maintenance responsibilities, as G4Lets were trying to pass these costs on to the tenants.

Happily, these tenants received back just over £1000 of the £1900 that G4Lets were trying to deduct. Nearly all of the charges for maintenance that is the landlord’s responsibility (unblocking drains, replacing locks) were dropped. The cleaning fee was lowered, and the painting fee was lowered considerably – from just over £1100 to just over £300. For us, what this shows is that G4Lets try it on; they pile in as many deductions as possible, refuse to lower them when challenged, and then hope that tenants won’t pursue the issue via the disputes procedure. For them and their landlords, deposit theft is a lucrative business.

With the tenant who had just moved in to a property that was uninhabitable, we organised to help him assert his basic rights as a tenant. This included that the house needed to be habitable for human habitation (as per section 10 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985), as well as the landlord’s responsibility for plumbing and sanitation (section 11 of the same Act). When G4Lets responded aggressively, such as by insisting that the tenant be in for contractor visits arranged to suit them and not him, he asserted his right to refuse entry and for visits to be arranged at a mutually agreeable time. G4Lets again responded aggressively to this, with one of the directors turning up at the house unannounced to try and intimidate the tenant. We again supported the tenant to assert his right to not be harassed by the agency for demanding basic repairs, as well as opening up a formal complaint with them.

Agencies are regulated by a body called the Property Ombudsman. Before a tenant can complain to the Ombudsman, they have to complain to the agency. This was why we advised the tenant to complain to G4Lets – so that he could then threaten to take his complaint to the Ombudsman. Happily, this threat produced a good result. G4Lets apologised for turning up at the house unannounced, as well as giving this tenant: a one month rent rebate, new white goods, and undertaking necessary repairs. They have also given a written promise that no cleaning deductions will be made at the end of the tenancy.

We think that, given how difficult G4Lets are to damage as an agency, and how much they (often successfully) rely on intimidation and the vulnerabilities of student tenants to keep their profits flowing, this is a good result. The deposit dispute tenants got over half their money back, whilst the other tenant now has a habitable property and some compensation.

There are limitations to this approach – MyDeposits takes a total of 3-4 months to reach a decision in a deposit dispute, leaving tenants out of pocket at a really inconvenient time and with no guarantee of any money being returned. Complaints to agencies also take time to process (15 working days), and they will only make any concessions if they feel under pressure. Had it been necessary to take this issue through the Ombudsman, this also would have taken time. Further, these kinds of procedures privatise these problems, leaving tenants dealing with them in an isolated way. However, in this situation, using these procedures was the most likely way to get a result, and also helped these tenants feel empowered. Whilst these procedures are designed to isolate tenants, there are ways to combat this – meeting up to collectively work through paperwork to dispute deposit deductions, for example, and sharing and explaining basic legal knowledge so that tenants feel able to assert their rights and explain them to their friends.

With the deposit dispute in particular, what we’ve also learned about G4Lets is the extent to which they rely on dragging the situation out and making it so stressful for tenants that they give up on trying to get their money back. With a lot of work, it’s possible for tenants to get some of their money back through MyDeposits.  A much quicker way for tenants to get all of their deposit back would be to simply not pay their last month’s rent. Based on our experiences of G4Lets over the past year and a half, this is what we are recommending that their tenants this year do: withhold their final month’s rent to get their deposit back.

We’re not suggesting that they do this alone – we want to organise with any G4Lets tenant who’s interested in doing this. We explain why we think it’s a good idea in the G4Lets rent strike area of our website, which includes an FAQ that covers some common concerns. If you’re interested in finding out more, you should check out the FAQ. You can contact also us at housing@brightonsolfed.org.uk.

G4Lets might have won the battle last year, but these two disputes show that tenants are going to win the war.

    • deposits
    • disrepair
    • G4Lets
    • victories
    • Brighton

    Guides

    Your rights at work

    About SolFed

    About SolFed

    Do you sometimes feel your union isn’t listening to you? (Solidarity Federation Education Union - SFEU)

    SFEU-flyer-2024-front

    What is wage theft?

    What is wage theft

    This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for

    this-is-our-flag

    Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    sfhwu leaflet front

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Why do we organise? Capitalism is shit, oppression is shit - but what can we at SolFed do about it?

    Why do we organise?

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Don't cross picket lines! Solidarity is the most powerful force in the world

    Don't cross picket lines

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    SolFed supports trans liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    SolFed supports Trans Liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    There's power in a union

    theres-power-in-a-union

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    RSS feed

    The Solidarity Federation is an anarcho-syndicalist union, a means for people seeking to improve our lives to organise in our workplaces and communities. SolFed brings together people in all occupations regardless of industry, sector or trade – whether we’re employed or not.

    SolFed seeks the abolition of capitalism and the institutions of power that are associated with it, such as the state. Our goal is to create a society centred on needs rather than profit, based upon the principle ‘from each according to ability, to each according to need’.

    We believe in the principle of direct action – that means doing something for ourselves and not expecting leaders or representatives to act on our behalf.

    SolFed members organise ourselves in a federation of local unions; in education we are in the Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU) and our members in hospitality are in the Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    Join us!