Skip to main content
Home
Solidarity Federation
Section of the International Workers Association
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
User account menu
  • Contact
  • Log in
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
  • Home
    • About SolFed
    • Workplace organiser training
    • Industrial strategy
    • Community strategy
    • Constitution
  • SolFed
    • Brighton
    • Bristol
    • Edinburgh
    • Liverpool
    • Manchester
    • North London
    • Wales
    • Yorkshire
  • Industries and sectors
    • Claimants and unpaid
    • Education
    • Health and social care
    • Hospitality
  • Events & reports
  • Publications
    • Guides
      • Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)
      • Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)
      • Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)
      • Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016) [en es]
      • A migrant's guide to London (2014) [en es pl]
      • Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)
    • Pamphlets and books
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)
      • Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)
      • Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)
      • The Economics of freedom (2003)
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism (2001)
      • Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)
      • Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)
    • Leaflets and flyers
      • Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU)
      • Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)
      • What is wage theft?
      • Why do we organise?
      • This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for
      • What is anarcho-syndicalism anyway?
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism (short version)
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism
      • Towards a better union
      • Protest is not enough
      • Building beyond elections
      • We should run our workplaces
      • We should run our communities
      • We should run our movements
    • Posters and stickers
    • Newsletters
      • Brighton Solidarity
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #2 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #4 (Winter 2014)
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (Summer 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #2 (Spring 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #1 (Jan 2012)
        • Brighton Solidarity - spending review special (Oct 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity - emergency budget special (Jun 2010)
        • Brighton Agitator #1 (Mar 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity (Winter 2007)
      • Communication Worker
        • Communication Worker #8 (Jul 2001)
        • Communication Worker #7 (Jan 2001)
        • Communication Worker #6
        • Communication Worker #5
        • Communication Worker bulletin
      • Education Worker
        • Education Worker #10 (Apr 2013)
        • Education Worker #9 (Oct 2012)
        • Education Worker #8 (Mar 2012)
        • Education Worker #7 (Mar 2011)
        • Education Worker #6 (Jan 2011)
        • Education Worker #5 (Oct 2009)
        • Education Worker #4 (May 2009)
        • Education Worker #3 (Sep 2008)
        • Education Worker #2 (Jan 2008)
        • Education Worker #1 (2007)
        • Education Worker #9 (Summer 2002)
        • Education Worker #8 - special higher education issue (2002)
      • The Leveller
        • The Leveller #19 (May-Jul 2017)
        • The Leveller #18 (Aug 2016)
        • The Leveller #17 (Mar 2015)
        • The Leveller #17 (Dec 2014)
        • The Leveller #16 (Nov 2014)
        • The Leveller #15 (May 2014)
        • The Leveller #14 (Mar 2014)
        • The Leveller #13 (May 2013)
        • The Leveller #12 (Jun-Jul 2012)
        • The Leveller #11 (May 2012)
        • The Leveller #10 (Apr 2012)
        • The Leveller #9 (Mar 2012)
        • The Leveller #6 (May-Jul 2011)
      • Liverpool Anarchist
        • Liverpool Anarchist #21 (Apr 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #20 (Mar 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #19 (Feb 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #18 (Dec 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #17 (Nov 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #16 (Oct 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #15 (Sep 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #14 (Aug 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #13 (Jul 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #12 (Jun 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #11 (Apr 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #10 (Dec 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #9 (Oct 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #8 (Aug 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #7 (Jul 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #6 (Mar 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #5 (Feb 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #4 (Jan 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #3 (Dec 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #2 (Nov 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #1 (Oct 2019)
      • May Day Bulletin (Newcastle, 2014)
      • Public Service Workers Network bulletin
        • Public Service Workers Network #8 (Winter 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #6 (Spring 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #5 (Oct-Nov 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #4 (Jun-Jul 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #3 (Autumn 1993)
      • Spanner in the Works (West Yorkshire, April 2013)
      • Wildcat!
        • Wildcat! #13 (Jan 2013)
        • Wildcat! (Winter 2012)
        • Wildcat! #6 (Summer 2011)
        • Wildcat! #5 (Spring 2011)
        • Wildcat! #4 (Dec 2010)
        • Wildcat! #3 (Oct-Nov 2010)
        • Wildcat! #2 (Jul-Aug 2010)
        • Wildcat! Football for the fans NOT for fat cats! (Jul 2010)
        • Wildcat! #1 (May-June 2010)
    • Direct Action
      • Direct Action - Solidarity Federation
        • Direct Action #2
        • Direct Action #1
        • Direct Action #48 (Autumn 2009)
        • Direct Action #47 (Summer 2009)
        • Direct Action #46 (Spring 2009)
        • Direct Action #45 (Winter 2008)
        • Direct Action #44 (Autumn 2008)
        • Direct Action #43 (Summer 2008)
        • Direct Action #42 (Spring 2008)
        • Direct Action #41 (Winter 2007)
        • Direct Action #40 (Autumn 2007)
        • Direct Action #39 (Summer 2007)
        • Direct Action #38 (Spring 2007)
        • Direct Action #37 (Autumn-Winter 2006)
        • Direct Action #36 (Spring-Summer 2006)
        • Direct Action #35 (Summer 2005)
        • Direct Action #34 (Spring 2005)
        • Direct Action #33 (Winter 2004)
        • Direct Action #32 (Autumn 2004)
        • Direct Action #31 (Summer 2004)
        • Direct Action #30 (Spring 2004)
        • Direct Action #29 (Winter 2003)
        • Direct Action #28 (Autumn 2003)
        • Direct Action #27 (Summer 2003)
        • Direct Action #26 (Spring 2003)
        • Direct Action #25 (Winter 2002)
        • Direct Action #24 (Autumn 2002)
        • Direct Action #23 (Summer 2002)
        • Direct Action #22 (Spring 2002)
        • Direct Action #21 (Winter 2001)
        • Direct Action #20 (Autumn 2001)
        • Direct Action #19 (Summer 2001)
        • Direct Action #18 (Spring 2001)
        • Direct Action #17 (Winter 2000)
        • Direct Action #16 (Autumn 2000)
        • Direct Action #15 (Summer 2000)
        • Direct Action #14 (Spring 2000)
        • Direct Action #13 (Winter 1999)
        • Direct Action #12 (Autumn 1999)
        • Direct Action #11 (Summer 1999)
        • Direct Action #10 (Spring 1999)
        • Direct Action #9 (Winter 1998)
        • Direct Action #8 (Autumn 1998)
        • Direct Action #7 (Summer 1998)
        • Direct Action #6 (Spring 1998)
        • Direct Action #5 (Winter 1997)
        • Direct Action #4 (Autumn 1997)
        • Direct Action #3 (Summer 1997)
        • Direct Action #2 (Spring 1997)
        • Direct Action #1 (Autumn 1996)
        • Direct Action #2 (Winter 1994)
        • Direct Action #1 (Summer 1994)
    • Catalyst
      • Catalyst - Solidarity Federation
        • Catalyst #31 (Oct 2013)
        • Catalyst #29 (Feb 2012)
        • Catalyst #28 (Oct 2011)
        • Catalyst #27 (Jun 2011)
        • Catalyst #26 (Mar 2011)
        • Catalyst #25 (Dec 2010)
        • Catalyst #24 (Summer 2010)
        • Catalyst #23 (Spring 2010)
        • Catalyst #22 (Winter 2009)
        • Catalyst #21 (Summer 2009)
        • Catalyst #20 (Sping 2009)
        • Catalyst #19 (Nov 2008)
        • Catalyst #18 (Sep 2008)
        • Catalyst #17 (July 2008)
        • Catalyst #16 (Spring 2007)
        • Catalyst #15 (Autumn 2006)
        • Catalyst #14 (Spring 2006)
        • Catalyst #13 (Summer 2005)
        • Catalyst #12 (Apr 2005)
        • Catalyst #11 (Sep 2004)
        • Catalyst #10 (May 2004)
        • Catalyst #9 (Spring 2004)
        • Catalyst #8 (Autumn 2003)
        • Catalyst #7 (May 2003)
        • Catalyst #6 (Dec 2002)
        • Catalyst #5 (Dec 2001)
        • Catalyst #4 (May 2001)
        • Catalyst #3 (Feb 2001)
        • Catalyst #2 (Sep 2000)
        • Catalyst #1 (May 2000)
    • SelfEd
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism
    • Reference
      • Student Radicals - an incomplete history of protest at the University of Sussex 1971-1975 (Ed Goddard, 2011)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in the 20th Century (Vadim Damier, 2009)
      • Tom Brown's Syndicalism (1990)
      • Trade unionism or syndicalism? (Tom Brown, 1943)
      • The General Strike - vol 1 no 1 (Sam Mainwaring, 15 Feb 1904)
  • IWA

Protest is not enough

Book traversal links for North London - flyers and materials

  • Towards a better union
  • Up
  • Building beyond elections

Protest is not enoughTHE RIGHT TO PROTEST

The right to protest is a key right within our political system, and the suppression of protest is a sign that a government has become oppressive and authoritarian. Protest is seen as the voice of the people, and an important tactic to raise issues and push for changes that the political system would otherwise ignore.

However, protest has also had a very uneven record of bringing about such changes, especially on its own without other forms of political action. This pamphlet will argue that this is due to the limited ability of passive protest to effect politics, and will discuss other tactics outside of the formal political system that are needed in order for people to assert their interests against a government that often does not care about them.

WHEN GOVERNMENT FAILS

Protest is seen as a necessary part of a healthy society because our political system often fails to represent the interests of the people living under it. This is clear within an absolute dictatorship, in which a dictator has no formal responsibility to care about the wants and needs of their subjects, and can exploit and oppress them at will. The current “democracies” of the world are also far from perfect. Those of us who live under these democracies have no ability to veto any decision our government makes, no matter how unpopular that decision might be. Instead, we must wait for the next election, and even then there is no guarantee that any of the parties running for election will represent our views. Even within a theoretical perfect democracy, minorities can be ignored by the government.

This means that often we need to take action outside of the formal political system to make ourselves heard and put pressure on that system when it starts to behave in ways that are oppressive, exploitative, or negligent. Without such action, there is a risk that the political system will stop serving its subjects at all, and will become more and more insular, detached, and corrupt.

In our current society, protest is often the go-to tactic for trying to push against the political system when it starts to go off the rails. A mass of people on the streets is seen as a message to the government that people are unhappy with their policies, and that they should change their ways in order to maintain popular support. On almost all issues, the organisation of protest is the main tactic of political movements aside from running in elections.

A RIGHT WITHOUT TEETH

However, the reasons why protest is necessary and the legal and cultural ideas around what constitutes a legitimate use of protest are at odds with each other. Protest is necessary to restrain state corruption, malice, and negligence, yet acceptable and respectable protest tactics are often defined by being as peaceful and as non-disruptive as possible. The standard framework for such a protest is that everyone masses at point A, marches to point B in accordance with the instructions and limitations put on them by agents of the same government they are protesting, and then goes home.

The great flaw in such acceptable forms of protest is that they are just statements of discontent and do not put any immediate pressure on the government to change its behaviour. While a sufficiently large peaceful protest may make the current government worry about how people will vote in the next election, it does not do anything to force them to stop what they are doing right now. This is even more true when the issue is one that only affects a minority and so can be easily ignored in an election. Such pressure also has little effect on issues in which all the main political parties are in agreement; in such a situation there is no alternative for disgruntled voters to turn to.

DISRUPTIVE PROTEST

The alternatives to the acceptable protest, in which we are allowed to protest only in so far as we do not actually put any pressure on the government, are more active and disruptive forms of protest that attempt to impose costs on the government if it continues with a harmful policy. This can range from non-violent civil disobedience, to refusal to cooperate or pay tax, to more active and lively blockades, and up to vandalism and riots.

It is not the place of such a short pamphlet to discuss the practical or ethical pros and cons of the tactics within the umbrella of “disruptive protest” or advocate for any particular approach. However, it is important to move beyond a model of protest as a way of showing discontent to a model of protest that imposes costs on oppressive and exploitative behaviour and pressures governments to avoid such behaviour. Without a willingness to do so, protest has no ability to restrain a government, as they can simply ignore protests without any fear of consequences. The right to protest is worthless if it is only a right to ineffective protest.

AT HOME, AT WORK

To be truly effective, our protests must also move away from a focus on the formal political system. While the government often enables and supports institutions that profit off of human misery, such institutions can still be confronted directly without having to rely on government action. For example, companies that profit from and support harmful state policies, such as arms manufacturers, oil companies, or corrupt service providers, can be directly targeted by disruptive protests or boycotts that put pressure on them to change their behaviour.

Many of the problems that we face are also not just political but more broadly social and economic in nature. Often our landlord or employer has a more direct influence on our lives than the government does, and things like high rents, low wages, and bigotry and abuse by petty authorities are the base cause of a series of other social ills. These problems can be confronted by labour strikes, rent strikes, boycotts, and other disruptive action.

Such organisation and protest around local economic and social issues has advantages over purely political protest. It allows for movements to be effective even when they are too small to directly confront the state. For example; It may take millions of people to force a government to take action on low wages, but we only need our co-workers to strike for higher wages in our specific workplaces, or some local allies to picket a local business that is behaving is a racist or sexist manner.

Starting with local bottom up organising and building up from there also creates more durable a capable movements. A protest movement that is built from the top down around a single pressing political issue will start to demobilise and disintegrate after that campaign is over, and any new campaign over a new issue will have to start again almost from scratch. Bottom up movements can continue to operate locally and maintain knowledge, relationships, and infrastructure in-between big unifying campaigns. They do not just create one off protest movements, but also build long term capacity within society to organise and to protest.

DIRECT ACTION

The next step to improve the effectiveness of our movements is to operate beyond the logic of protest and incorporate the principal of direct action. Direct action is the idea that instead of putting pressure on an institution to implement a change that we desire, we organise to achieve that change directly. This can be constructive, such as organising a food cooperative or a mutual aid network to directly provide services that the state or capitalism will not, or it can be obstructive and focus on protecting us from harm, such as organising anti-raids or anti-fascist groups to directly prevent nationalist and racist thugs from threatening our communities, whether those thugs are state sponsored or not.

Direct action is important because protest, even when successful in pushing an institution to change, still leaves the implementation of that change in the hands of the very leaders who had to be forced into adopting it. Such leaders cannot be trusted to act in good faith, and they will often implement reforms in the weakest way possible, backslide later, or simply lie about their intentions and fail to implement any reform at all. Sometimes the best way to achieve something is to do it ourselves.

ORGANISING AS EQUALS

Many previous movements for social justice have been channelled into serving the interests of their leaders instead of the interests of the people they claimed to help or represent. Many formal, top down charities have become more about keeping their executives well paid than about helping people. Workers’ movements like the trade union movement and the cooperative movement have drifted from their original objective of empowering workers to becoming more and more similar to the capitalist businesses they were created to oppose.

To avoid this kind of failure and build more reliable movements we need to avoid creating structures in which one person or group of people, even if they are elected, sits at the top of an organisation and dictates what to do to everyone else. We need to build these organisations on mutual agreement and consensus so that no one can be ignored. We also need to build them from the bottom up, with each local organisation running its own affairs according to the knowledge and insight of those who actually work and live within that local area, so that we avoid creating a new unaccountable hierarchy.

Hierarchies in which those at the top can command and ignore those below them are the problem that causes the need for protest and resistance in the first place. Our political leaders can act without any real accountability to those below them, and this is why movements outside of the formal political system are necessary to keep them in check. If we simply recreate such hierarchical structures within our movements then we will recreate the same kind of problems we are struggling against.

The principles behind protest and direct action themselves are incompatible with blind obedience to leadership, as they are founded on the idea that people have the right and the ability to look at society, decide what needs to change, organise with like minded allies, and take action to create that change regardless of what those above them think. Indeed, previous movements that became more hierarchical often had to abandon disruptive protest and direct action because such tactics undermined the obedience that the leadership relied on to control those movements.

DUAL POWER

As bottom up organisations grow, they can network, form alliances, and even form federations that allow them to cooperate with each other and achieve more than they could alone. A small group might only be able to deal with very specific local issues, but an alliance of such groups across a country can deal with nationwide issues. They can form a system of popular power that is completely independent form the state and capitalism and is not reliant on the whims of politicians or property owners to ensure that peoples’ desires are met.

A network of peoples’ councils spread throughout communities and workplaces, that is organised from the bottom up to truly empower its membership, would have effective control over much of the real infrastructure of the area it operates in. Workers could refuse to manufacture dangerous goods or implement unfair management decisions. Evictions, immigration raids, and arrests could be prevented. Exploitative rents, taxes, charges, and prices could be ignored. Unpopular laws could be made completely unenforceable. Important resources and infrastructure could be seized and run by workers and service users in the interests of all those involved instead of to enrich capitalists and empower politicians.

All of the above has been achieved by past mass movements willing to take up disruption and direct action to achieve their aims. Corrupt or incompetent governments and exploitative capitalist businesses can be marginalised and ignored to the point that it is impossible for them to impose anything upon the people theoretically under them. The full development of such an alliance of local organisations for protest and direct action could not only provide us with far more potent tools to prevent the abuse of power by politicians or capitalists, but also give us the basis to abolish them entirely and run society in the interests of everyone.

ANARCHO-SYNDICALISM

The fact that protest is seen as so vital to a free society in order to keep political power in check indicates that our current political system does not in fact serve the desires of its subject without outside pressure. If we can build a movement that can articulate and further those desires in spite of, or against, an uncooperative government, then we will have built structures that are both more powerful than the state and more capable of serving our needs. At that point, it would only be sensible for that movement to do away with the state and organise society directly on its own. This would be a revolution that truly empowered and protected people instead of simply subordinating us to a new set of rulers.

This approach to building movements has a name. Because it is critical of hierarchies and all other forms of rulership and seeks to organise without resorting to that rulership, it is anarchist, which literally means without (an) rulers (archy). Because it seeks to build working class power though organisations in the workplace and the community, it is syndicalist, which comes from the French word for a workers’ union. Together, these two ideas form Anarcho-Syndicalism.

    Attachment Size
    protest-is-not-enough-london-colour-a5.pdf (94.05 KB) 94.05 KB

    Tags

    • library
    • publications
    • leaflets and flyers
    • demonstrations, pickets and protests
    • North London

    Guides

    Your rights at work

    About SolFed

    About SolFed

    Do you sometimes feel your union isn’t listening to you? (Solidarity Federation Education Union - SFEU)

    SFEU-flyer-2024-front

    What is wage theft?

    What is wage theft

    This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for

    this-is-our-flag

    Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    sfhwu leaflet front

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Why do we organise? Capitalism is shit, oppression is shit - but what can we at SolFed do about it?

    Why do we organise?

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Don't cross picket lines! Solidarity is the most powerful force in the world

    Don't cross picket lines

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    SolFed supports trans liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    SolFed supports Trans Liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    There's power in a union

    theres-power-in-a-union

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    RSS feed

    The Solidarity Federation is an anarcho-syndicalist union, a means for people seeking to improve our lives to organise in our workplaces and communities. SolFed brings together people in all occupations regardless of industry, sector or trade – whether we’re employed or not.

    SolFed seeks the abolition of capitalism and the institutions of power that are associated with it, such as the state. Our goal is to create a society centred on needs rather than profit, based upon the principle ‘from each according to ability, to each according to need’.

    We believe in the principle of direct action – that means doing something for ourselves and not expecting leaders or representatives to act on our behalf.

    SolFed members organise ourselves in a federation of local unions; in education we are in the Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU) and our members in hospitality are in the Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    Join us!