Skip to main content
Home
Solidarity Federation
Section of the International Workers Association
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
User account menu
  • Contact
  • Log in
CAPTCHA
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
  • Home
    • About SolFed
    • Workplace organiser training
    • Industrial strategy
    • Community strategy
    • Constitution
  • SolFed
    • Brighton
    • Bristol
    • Edinburgh
    • Liverpool
    • Manchester
    • North London
    • Wales
    • Yorkshire
  • Industries and sectors
    • Claimants and unpaid
    • Education
    • Health and social care
    • Hospitality
  • Events & reports
  • Publications
    • Guides
      • Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)
      • Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)
      • Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)
      • Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016) [en es]
      • A migrant's guide to London (2014) [en es pl]
      • Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)
    • Pamphlets and books
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)
      • Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)
      • Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)
      • Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)
      • Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)
      • The Economics of freedom (2003)
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism (2001)
      • Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)
      • Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)
    • Leaflets and flyers
      • Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU)
      • Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)
      • What is wage theft?
      • Why do we organise?
      • This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for
      • What is anarcho-syndicalism anyway?
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism (short version)
      • Anarchism and Syndicalism
      • Towards a better union
      • Protest is not enough
      • Building beyond elections
      • We should run our workplaces
      • We should run our communities
      • We should run our movements
    • Posters and stickers
    • Newsletters
      • Brighton Solidarity
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #2 (2015)
        • Brighton Solidarity #4 (Winter 2014)
        • Brighton Solidarity #3 (Summer 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #2 (Spring 2014)
        • Direct Action Solidarity #1 (Jan 2012)
        • Brighton Solidarity - spending review special (Oct 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity - emergency budget special (Jun 2010)
        • Brighton Agitator #1 (Mar 2010)
        • Brighton Solidarity (Winter 2007)
      • Communication Worker
        • Communication Worker #8 (Jul 2001)
        • Communication Worker #7 (Jan 2001)
        • Communication Worker #6
        • Communication Worker #5
        • Communication Worker bulletin
      • Education Worker
        • Education Worker #10 (Apr 2013)
        • Education Worker #9 (Oct 2012)
        • Education Worker #8 (Mar 2012)
        • Education Worker #7 (Mar 2011)
        • Education Worker #6 (Jan 2011)
        • Education Worker #5 (Oct 2009)
        • Education Worker #4 (May 2009)
        • Education Worker #3 (Sep 2008)
        • Education Worker #2 (Jan 2008)
        • Education Worker #1 (2007)
        • Education Worker #9 (Summer 2002)
        • Education Worker #8 - special higher education issue (2002)
      • The Leveller
        • The Leveller #19 (May-Jul 2017)
        • The Leveller #18 (Aug 2016)
        • The Leveller #17 (Mar 2015)
        • The Leveller #17 (Dec 2014)
        • The Leveller #16 (Nov 2014)
        • The Leveller #15 (May 2014)
        • The Leveller #14 (Mar 2014)
        • The Leveller #13 (May 2013)
        • The Leveller #12 (Jun-Jul 2012)
        • The Leveller #11 (May 2012)
        • The Leveller #10 (Apr 2012)
        • The Leveller #9 (Mar 2012)
        • The Leveller #6 (May-Jul 2011)
      • Liverpool Anarchist
        • Liverpool Anarchist #21 (Apr 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #20 (Mar 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #19 (Feb 2022)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #18 (Dec 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #17 (Nov 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #16 (Oct 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #15 (Sep 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #14 (Aug 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #13 (Jul 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #12 (Jun 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #11 (Apr 2021)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #10 (Dec 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #9 (Oct 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #8 (Aug 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #7 (Jul 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #6 (Mar 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #5 (Feb 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #4 (Jan 2020)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #3 (Dec 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #2 (Nov 2019)
        • Liverpool Anarchist #1 (Oct 2019)
      • May Day Bulletin (Newcastle, 2014)
      • Public Service Workers Network bulletin
        • Public Service Workers Network #8 (Winter 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #6 (Spring 1995)
        • Public Service Workers Network #5 (Oct-Nov 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #4 (Jun-Jul 1994)
        • Public Service Workers Network #3 (Autumn 1993)
      • Spanner in the Works (West Yorkshire, April 2013)
      • Wildcat!
        • Wildcat! #13 (Jan 2013)
        • Wildcat! (Winter 2012)
        • Wildcat! #6 (Summer 2011)
        • Wildcat! #5 (Spring 2011)
        • Wildcat! #4 (Dec 2010)
        • Wildcat! #3 (Oct-Nov 2010)
        • Wildcat! #2 (Jul-Aug 2010)
        • Wildcat! Football for the fans NOT for fat cats! (Jul 2010)
        • Wildcat! #1 (May-June 2010)
    • Direct Action
      • Direct Action - Solidarity Federation
        • Direct Action #2
        • Direct Action #1
        • Direct Action #48 (Autumn 2009)
        • Direct Action #47 (Summer 2009)
        • Direct Action #46 (Spring 2009)
        • Direct Action #45 (Winter 2008)
        • Direct Action #44 (Autumn 2008)
        • Direct Action #43 (Summer 2008)
        • Direct Action #42 (Spring 2008)
        • Direct Action #41 (Winter 2007)
        • Direct Action #40 (Autumn 2007)
        • Direct Action #39 (Summer 2007)
        • Direct Action #38 (Spring 2007)
        • Direct Action #37 (Autumn-Winter 2006)
        • Direct Action #36 (Spring-Summer 2006)
        • Direct Action #35 (Summer 2005)
        • Direct Action #34 (Spring 2005)
        • Direct Action #33 (Winter 2004)
        • Direct Action #32 (Autumn 2004)
        • Direct Action #31 (Summer 2004)
        • Direct Action #30 (Spring 2004)
        • Direct Action #29 (Winter 2003)
        • Direct Action #28 (Autumn 2003)
        • Direct Action #27 (Summer 2003)
        • Direct Action #26 (Spring 2003)
        • Direct Action #25 (Winter 2002)
        • Direct Action #24 (Autumn 2002)
        • Direct Action #23 (Summer 2002)
        • Direct Action #22 (Spring 2002)
        • Direct Action #21 (Winter 2001)
        • Direct Action #20 (Autumn 2001)
        • Direct Action #19 (Summer 2001)
        • Direct Action #18 (Spring 2001)
        • Direct Action #17 (Winter 2000)
        • Direct Action #16 (Autumn 2000)
        • Direct Action #15 (Summer 2000)
        • Direct Action #14 (Spring 2000)
        • Direct Action #13 (Winter 1999)
        • Direct Action #12 (Autumn 1999)
        • Direct Action #11 (Summer 1999)
        • Direct Action #10 (Spring 1999)
        • Direct Action #9 (Winter 1998)
        • Direct Action #8 (Autumn 1998)
        • Direct Action #7 (Summer 1998)
        • Direct Action #6 (Spring 1998)
        • Direct Action #5 (Winter 1997)
        • Direct Action #4 (Autumn 1997)
        • Direct Action #3 (Summer 1997)
        • Direct Action #2 (Spring 1997)
        • Direct Action #1 (Autumn 1996)
        • Direct Action #2 (Winter 1994)
        • Direct Action #1 (Summer 1994)
    • Catalyst
      • Catalyst - Solidarity Federation
        • Catalyst #31 (Oct 2013)
        • Catalyst #29 (Feb 2012)
        • Catalyst #28 (Oct 2011)
        • Catalyst #27 (Jun 2011)
        • Catalyst #26 (Mar 2011)
        • Catalyst #25 (Dec 2010)
        • Catalyst #24 (Summer 2010)
        • Catalyst #23 (Spring 2010)
        • Catalyst #22 (Winter 2009)
        • Catalyst #21 (Summer 2009)
        • Catalyst #20 (Sping 2009)
        • Catalyst #19 (Nov 2008)
        • Catalyst #18 (Sep 2008)
        • Catalyst #17 (July 2008)
        • Catalyst #16 (Spring 2007)
        • Catalyst #15 (Autumn 2006)
        • Catalyst #14 (Spring 2006)
        • Catalyst #13 (Summer 2005)
        • Catalyst #12 (Apr 2005)
        • Catalyst #11 (Sep 2004)
        • Catalyst #10 (May 2004)
        • Catalyst #9 (Spring 2004)
        • Catalyst #8 (Autumn 2003)
        • Catalyst #7 (May 2003)
        • Catalyst #6 (Dec 2002)
        • Catalyst #5 (Dec 2001)
        • Catalyst #4 (May 2001)
        • Catalyst #3 (Feb 2001)
        • Catalyst #2 (Sep 2000)
        • Catalyst #1 (May 2000)
    • SelfEd
      • A history of anarcho-syndicalism
    • Reference
      • Student Radicals - an incomplete history of protest at the University of Sussex 1971-1975 (Ed Goddard, 2011)
      • Anarcho-syndicalism in the 20th Century (Vadim Damier, 2009)
      • Tom Brown's Syndicalism (1990)
      • Trade unionism or syndicalism? (Tom Brown, 1943)
      • The General Strike - vol 1 no 1 (Sam Mainwaring, 15 Feb 1904)
  • IWA

Education round up 27 July 2012

By Choccy, 28 July, 2012
c

(Un)Qualified teachers wanted.
While the eyes of most people, both critical and uncritical, are drawn to the Olympics, secretary of state for Education, Michael Gove, has introduced possibly his most significant and destructive piece of reform.

Academies no longer need to employ qualified teachers to teach lessons. Gove heralds this as 'freedom' for academies to employ 'the best for the job'. So while trying to raise the profile of teaching, he's doing the exact opposite. But this is a smokescreen. This is nothing to do with profile, or improving education, or getting 'the best for the job'. It has everything to do with driving down pay and conditions.

Make no mistake, a qualification does not make you a 'good' teacher, and the governments yardsticks for 'good' are questionable at best., I have no faith in such judgements or the Ofsted framework. Likewise, there are people without a piece of paper saying 'IZ REAL TEACHER' who would probably be great with kids. But this is all a side issue. This reform is entirely about destroying national agreements over pay and conditions which teachers in state schools were entitled to.

It's important to mention that this sort of thing is happening elsewhere. RMT members are currently not undertaking duties outside their job description and refusing to operate stations being staffed by untrained temp Customer Service Assistants (ICSAs) - trains aren't to stop at stations where these ICSAs are being used to top up under-staffing on the cheap. Underground staff feel the unqualified staff not only undermine pay and conditions but pose health and safety concerns.

Similar concerns are relevant in the classroom. We don't just teach history, music, science whatever, we are also responsible for every single pupil in a classroom during lesson time, and are 'trained' to deal with a wide variety of circumstances, training that is supposed to be developed regularly, but sure they won't even pay for that either.

Pay & conditions
Now, academies have always had the freedom to deviate from the national pay scale, but in practice they haven't. This is because they were still required to employ qualified teachers - those possessing Qualified Teacher Status, or QTS. This status is conferred to those with qualifications such as PGCE, GTP or Teach First, amongst a few others. Now,because they were employing qualified teachers, in a 'job market' even in a recession, it's hard to get and retain staff if you don't pay 'the going rate' - and the going rate in this case is the national pay scale in state schools.

But, along came Gove to remedy this pesky barrier to profiteering. Academies no longer have to employ qualified teachers, opening the pool of desperate workers who fancy a go at teaching. More prospective 'teachers', more job competition, more desperation, lower wages, worse conditions. Those that chose to work as non-qualified teachers will almost certainly be getting shafted, probably earning 8-10k a year less than a 'qualified' teacher - so no one is a winner here except academy sponsors.

Profiteering
Academies can make profits, Gove has no problem with this, But how is profit made in a sector without paying 'customers'?

Academies receive their funding direct from Whitehall, rather than their local authority. This will be a fixed amount. They can then 'buy in' their services. So by buying in services in a 'competitive' market they can 'save' money. Likewise they can save money by now paying unqualified staff to teach lessons. Any surplus generated is ££PROFIT££. Who gets this profit? It gets put back into the school right? DOES IT FUCK. The sponsors rake it in.

It makes sense why carpet sellers are taking over schools like Downhills Primary in Tottenham against the wishes of workers, pupils and parents. Because there's money to be made. Makes even more sense to start running chains like ARK, AET, and Harris.

Altering teacher education
For years the government has been running down postgraduate teaching courses, stating it wants more 'on the job' training for teachers. This means removing any critical theoretical component from teacher education, such as sociology of education, philosophy of education, psychology of learning and so on.

This all had it's faults, absolutely, but there was room for asking questions like 'are schools the right thing to do?', 'are uniforms a good idea?'. The move to 'on the job' training all but removes what was left of this, and turns teaching into service-delivery, manufacturing the next generation of menially-skilled workplace fodder.

The tensions are obvious. This move further proletarianises teaching, eroding the myth of 'professionalism' that many had bought into. Such 'professionalism' while helping win recognition for teaching and securing better pay and conditions, by attempting to put teaching on par with other 'professions', also resulted in a somewhat more conservative current within teaching. It's not a PINKO LEFTY profession. You won't find jaded lefties with elbow patches on their jackets. You'll find driven 27 year old ex-City-workers in suits. Those that stay longer than three years are almost certainly careerists with managerial aspirations. In academies, of which there are over 1,700 nationally (compared to less than 300 two years ago), teachers over the age of 30 are a noticeable rarity.

Is this what parents want?
As if Gove cares anyway, but the answer is NO:

- From the NUT: "Our 2011 ComRes poll showed that 89% of parents want a qualified teacher to teach their child, with just 1% comfortable about those without Qualified Teacher Status (QTS) taking charge of a class.

By his own admission, Michael Gove is relaxed about profit-making from schools. He takes his inspiration from Sweden where profits are being made by reducing the number of qualified teachers, and where educational standards have fallen. By contrast, the reason Finland scores so highly in international tables is because they value teachers, trust teachers and pay teachers well.

“Parents and teachers will see this as a cost-cutting measure that will cause irreparable damage to children’s education. Schools need a properly resourced team of qualified teachers and support staff, not lower investment dressed up as ‘freedoms’"

So parents don't want it, workers certainly won't want it, and no one bothers to ask kids anyway. But none of this matters to Gove anyway.

Gove chose a perfect day to introduce this stunning move. While no one is looking. And by the time we wake up it will already be reality.

    • schools and academies
    • National Union of Teachers (NUT)
    • education
    • pay and conditions
    • privatisation
    • Education Workers Network (EWN)
    • Education Worker posts

    Guides

    Your rights at work

    About SolFed

    About SolFed

    Do you sometimes feel your union isn’t listening to you? (Solidarity Federation Education Union - SFEU)

    SFEU-flyer-2024-front

    What is wage theft?

    What is wage theft

    This is our flag - it tells you what we stand for

    this-is-our-flag

    Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    sfhwu leaflet front

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Stuff your boss (doesn't want you to know)

    Why do we organise? Capitalism is shit, oppression is shit - but what can we at SolFed do about it?

    Why do we organise?

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Stuff your sexist boss (doesn't want you to know) (2018)

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Cost of living - Organise and fight back with the Solidarity Federation

    Don't cross picket lines! Solidarity is the most powerful force in the world

    Don't cross picket lines

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Direct Action #2 (2024)

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Don't just moan - Organise!

    Is your cleaning job killing you? A guide to cleaners health and safety (2017)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Stuff your landlord (doesn't want you to know) (2016)

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    Fed up with your landlord? Organise and fight back!

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    A migrant's guide to Manchester (2016)

    SolFed supports trans liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    SolFed supports Trans Liberation - transphobia is a workplace and housing issue

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Office worker’s health and safety - your rights and how to use them (2015)

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Solidarity Federation - Where we stand

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Anarcho-syndicalism in Britain – a little history (2015)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Strike - a guide to walking out (2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    Anarchism and Anarcho-syndicalism (Rudolf Rocker, 2014)

    There's power in a union

    theres-power-in-a-union

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    A migrant's guide to London (2014)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Fighting for ourselves - anarcho-syndicalism and the class struggle (2012)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    Theory & Practice 1 - Workmates - direct action workplace organising on the London underground (2011)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    The Economics of freedom (2003)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    A history of anarcho-syndicalism (SelfEd Collective, 24 unit series, 2001)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Out of the frying pan, a critical look at works councils (1998)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Health and safety at work - an anarcho-syndicalist approach (1997)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    Theory & Practice 2 - Anarcho-syndicalism in Puerto Real (1994)

    RSS feed

    The Solidarity Federation is an anarcho-syndicalist union, a means for people seeking to improve our lives to organise in our workplaces and communities. SolFed brings together people in all occupations regardless of industry, sector or trade – whether we’re employed or not.

    SolFed seeks the abolition of capitalism and the institutions of power that are associated with it, such as the state. Our goal is to create a society centred on needs rather than profit, based upon the principle ‘from each according to ability, to each according to need’.

    We believe in the principle of direct action – that means doing something for ourselves and not expecting leaders or representatives to act on our behalf.

    SolFed members organise ourselves in a federation of local unions; in education we are in the Solidarity Federation Education Union (SFEU) and our members in hospitality are in the Solidarity Federation Hospitality Workers Union (SFHWU)

    Join us!